-
Adotados on 18/06/2026 - Bureau decision date: 02/12/2025ReferênciaCCMI/259-EESC-2026Opinion TypeOptionalCommission ReferencesCo-rapporteur(PolandPlenary session number606-
European Economic
and Social Committee
Opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee – Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions – RESourceEU Action Plan Accelerating our critical raw materials strategy to adapt to a new reality (COM(2025) 945 final)
Opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee – Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions – RESourceEU Action Plan Accelerating our critical raw materials strategy to adapt to a new reality (COM(2025) 945 final)
Opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee – Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions – RESourceEU Action Plan Accelerating our critical raw materials strategy to adapt to a new reality (COM(2025) 945 final)
EESC 2026/00431
OJ C, C/2026/4655, 23.9.2026, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/C/2026/4655/oj (BG, ES, CS, DA, DE, ET, EL, EN, FR, GA, HR, IT, LV, LT, HU, MT, NL, PL, PT, RO, SK, SL, FI, SV)
| Official Journal | EN C series |
| C/2026/4655 | 23.9.2026 |
Opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee
Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions
RESourceEU Action Plan Accelerating our critical raw materials strategy to adapt to a new reality
(COM(2025) 945 final)
(C/2026/4655)
Rapporteur:
Konstantinos DIAMANTOUROS (EL-I)Co-rapporteur:
Agata MEYSNER (PL-Cat. 3)| Advisor | Laura BLAŽEVIĆ (to the Group I rapporteur) Robin ROELS (to the Cat. 3 co-rapporteur) |
| Bureau decision | 2.12.2025 |
| Legal basis | Article 304 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union |
| Referral | European Commission, 24.2.2026 |
| Section responsible | Consultative Commission on Industrial Change |
| Adopted in section | 20.5.2026 |
| Adopted at plenary session | 17.6.2026 |
| Plenary session No | 606 |
| Outcome of vote (for/against/abstentions) | 174/0/1 |
1. Conclusions and recommendations
The EESC considers the RESourceEU Action Plan to be an important step towards strengthening the resilience of the EU’s critical raw materials value chains and reducing strategic dependencies. However, achieving this objective will require a balanced approach that combines greater European production capacity, circularity and responsible international partnerships with competitive energy prices, feasible regulatory frameworks and robust environmental and social safeguards. The EESC therefore highlights the following priorities:
| 1.1. | facilitating strategic European projects and faster permitting: reduce structurally high industrial energy prices and facilitate long-term renewable power purchase agreements (PPAs). Ensure electrification support under the Clean Industrial State Aid Framework (CISAF) for energy-intensive industries, including the Innovation Fund (IF), while ensuring the effectiveness of the EU ETS and ensuring that initiatives like EU Taxonomy facilitate strategic projects’ access to finance; |
| 1.2. | while acknowledging the forthcoming revision of the Water Framework Directive, the EESC stresses that this process must not lead to any lowering of environmental standards; |
| 1.3. | improving recycling and reuse of critical raw materials: introduce a uniform export duty on aluminium scrap to retain value within the EU and improve the circulation of CRM waste through simplified and digitalised procedures under the Waste Shipments Regulation, with clear definitions of waste and secondary materials to facilitate recycling and recovery. Policy coherence must include material footprint mitigation objectives and sectoral plans to reduce material intensity to mitigate criticality in downstream sectors; |
| 1.4. | supporting investment and market development: strengthen the resilience of EU material value chains by combining greater domestic production with demand-side measures such as material efficiency, eco-design and higher recycling rates. Stockpiling should complement rather than replace EU domestic production, processing and recycling. Improve transparency in raw materials governance through better data on material flows, stock levels and allocation decisions; |
| 1.5. | building balanced international partnerships: diversify supply through strategic partnerships while strengthening EU extraction, processing, refining and recycling capacity. In the current geopolitical environment, there is no guarantee that previously trusted partners will remain stable or reliable suppliers of strategic materials. The Union should therefore reduce over-reliance on any single partner and pursue a diversified partnership strategy based on mutual benefit, transparency and strong environmental and labour standards. |
2. General comments
| 2.1. | Europe is entering a new phase of raw materials policy where speed, security and industrial scaling are key organising principles. The EESC recognises the urgency of reducing dependencies on insecure sources and building resilient value chains. Recent initiatives such as the Industrial Accelerator Act highlight the need to strengthen Europe’s industrial capacity and reduce dependencies. Ensuring that raw materials and their downstream applications are developed within Europe is essential for a ‘Made in the EU’ approach and for maintaining technological leadership in the clean transition. |
| 2.2. | At the same time, this urgency must not become a license for democratic shortcuts. A credible strategy must respect binding environmental law, workers’ rights and public participation to avoid project delays caused by conflict, litigation and reputational damage. RESourceEU should therefore be assessed also as a governance shift. Instruments such as joint purchasing, stockpiling and strategic prioritisation require clear accountability, transparency and oversight, including from social partners and civil society. The competitiveness agenda must comply with strict environmental and social obligations, as well as democratic standards, including access to justice. |
| 2.3. | The EESC welcomes the RESourceEU strategy, which builds on the Critical Raw Materials Act, the Clean Industrial Deal and the Steel and Metals Action Plan to strengthen the EU’s resilience to supply disruptions. Policy coherence must include material footprint mitigation objectives and sectoral plans to reduce material intensity to mitigate criticality – particularly in mobility, energy systems, construction and digital products – alongside strong eco-design, reuse, repair and longer product lifetimes, while supporting European supply chains to meet growing demand for strategic and critical materials. |
3. Promoting and accelerating priority projects
| 3.1. | The EESC stresses that regulatory frameworks exist to safeguard public interests, environmental integrity and workers’ rights and should therefore be improved. The current framework faces implementation bottlenecks, particularly due to administrative capacity constraints, energy price volatility and fragmented coordination across Member States. Social acceptance is a decisive condition for project viability and legitimacy and requires meaningful community engagement and strong civil and social dialogue from the earliest stages, including permitting, financing and partnerships. Public funding should, alongside corporate project development, support local authority capacity, independent expertise for communities and monitoring and enforcement. |
| 3.2. | The EU continues to suffer from structurally high energy prices compared to major competitors. Given the energy-intensive nature of many CRM activities (in some cases accounting for 50 % of operating expenses), energy costs are a key factor in determining project viability. While the Clean Industrial Deal represents a step in the right direction, it has had no impact on short-term energy prices. |
| 3.3. | The CISAF allows price support for industrial consumers but remains too restrictive to have a meaningful impact on CRM operators (1). Additionality and sourcing requirements – which usually mirror those applied to renewable hydrogen or require compliance with economically and technologically unfeasible options – linked to electrification support, risk excluding energy-intensive industries from accessing support. This happens especially in regions where electricity systems are still in transition, even though electrification already delivers significant emissions reductions. |
| 3.4. | Barriers also remain to deploying targeted measures in order to reduce energy costs, such as long-term PPAs. A key obstacle is the lack of support for profile matching/shaping and firming costs, as highlighted in the Draghi report, which has considerably slowed down the PPA market. Other schemes, such as Italy’s ‘Energy Release 2.0’, should be explored and adapted in other Member States. |
| 3.5. | The EESC recommends that the Commission facilitate the use of long-term PPAs for energy-intensive users and review the CISAF to ensure that electrification support can be effectively used by industry, contributing to the EU’s decarbonisation and competitiveness, without distorting competition. Such schemes should include strict public interest conditionality, including reporting, and explicit requirements on occupational health and safety, training, and quality jobs |
| 3.6. | Moreover, any such short-term support must come with clear conditions, including worker protection, community engagement, transparency of beneficiaries and safeguards against windfall gains, while prioritising targeted measures that structurally lower energy costs through grids, flexibility and efficiency. |
| 3.7. | Another factor increasing cost pressure on CRM operators is the Emissions Trading System (ETS). While the ETS has contributed to decarbonising the electricity mix, it represents a major cost for sectors with limited technological alternatives to reduce emissions. The EESC thus urges the Commission to assess the impact of the ETS on the economy, environment and competitiveness of CRMs as part of the ETS review, in line with the March EU Council Conclusions. At the same time, the ETS remains a key driver of EU decarbonisation and its integrity must be preserved. Any review should address how ETS-related costs interact with material efficiency measures, substitution strategies and circular material use, and it must avoid sector-specific exemptions that weaken the carbon price signal or shift costs onto other sectors, while ensuring that carbon leakage risks and international competitiveness are properly addressed. Where CRM production faces structural decarbonisation barriers, policy responses should prioritise innovation support, electrification, material efficiency and circularity, alongside targeted financing mechanisms. |
| 3.8. | Finally, CRM offtake agreements are influenced by the EU Taxonomy (2) and the ‘Do No Significant Harm’ (DNSH) principle. These agreements were established to ensure that public and private finance does not support activities that undermine the EU’s environmental integrity or investor confidence in green classification systems. However, current criteria and thresholds under the Taxonomy are not yet fully achievable with existing technologies for several CRM activities, with the result that certain strategic EU projects are in danger of exclusion from accessing finance even when they meet higher environmental, labour and transparency standards than third countries. These thresholds should be regularly revised and adjusted in line with technological progress. The spill-over effect of the DNSH principle in EU funding programmes and frameworks needs to be recalibrated to avoid unintentionally blocking projects from accessing funding |
| 3.9. | Assessment frameworks should distinguish between unavoidable impact intrinsic to primary extraction and avoidable harm resulting from sub-optimal practices where CRM projects are deemed strategic for the EU. Environmental protection relating to water resources, biodiversity, pollution prevention, human health and community impact must remain fully operational. Projects demonstrating materially lower lifecycle emissions than global competitors should not be classified as ‘doing significant harm’ and this should be reflected in assessment methodologies. A more holistic evaluation framework is required, integrating climate performance with biodiversity, water and pollution considerations. |
| 3.10. | The EESC notes that proposals on price floors or guaranteed minimum prices for certain critical raw materials pose a particular risk. While intended to provide investment certainty, such mechanisms may expose public finances to significant fiscal risk if commodity prices fall sharply, transferring market volatility to taxpayers. At the same time, high price volatility and long investment cycles characteristic of CRM projects can represent major barriers to investment in the EU and should be tackled. |
| 3.11. | The EESC welcomes the Commission’s intention to mobilise EUR 3 billion to support CRMs. However, financing needs are far greater and should be reflected in the next MFF. While the earmarking of EUR 1 billion under the IF’s 2025 call for clean-tech manufacturing projects focusing on CRM value chains is positive, the current evaluation criteria under the IF risk limiting its effectiveness for strategic raw material projects. In particular, the strong emphasis on a quantifiable degree of emission reductions places projects that primarily deliver security of supply, self-sufficiency, resilience and industrial capacity at a disadvantage. |
| 3.12. | The EESC welcomes the Commission’s plan to speed up environmental permitting. However, faster procedures must be accompanied by adequate investment in public authorities, as well as support for high-quality impact assessments, monitoring and enforcement capacity. Speeding up the process must not weaken the quality of impact assessments, public participation, access to justice, nature protection obligations or water protection requirements, and any simplification must be strictly administrative, not substantive. |
| 3.13. | While acknowledging the forthcoming revision of the Water Framework Directive, the EESC stresses that this process must not lead to any lowering of environmental standards. At the same time, it should address implementation challenges, including permitting procedures, and support the EU’s strategic autonomy through secure access to critical raw materials. |
4. Circularity and innovation
| 4.1. | Maximising the recovery and reuse of materials already placed on the EU market must be a central pillar of the EU’s raw materials and industrial strategy, alongside primary sourcing and diversification of supply. The EESC supports the emphasis on recycling CRMs and better use of existing waste streams. Strengthening circularity is essential to reduce dependencies, lower emissions and reinforce Europe’s resilience. Circularity is broader than recycling and must include extending product lifetimes and improving repairability, modularity and reusability, and it must shift from a waste management approach to resource stewardship. |
| 4.2. | The Commission’s announcement of targeted measures on aluminium scrap is therefore welcome and must be delivered without delay to ensure that CRM scrap generated in the EU contributes primarily to European recycling and manufacturing capacity. This may include appropriate export measures, such as a uniform export duty, to address market imbalances and prevent carbon and value leakage, while remaining compatible with the EU’s international obligations. Such measures should be proportionate, transparent and time-bound, with safeguards to prevent the externalisation of environmental damage (including damage arising from unsafe recycling practices, pollution and labour exploitation) and human rights risks and to ensure responsible value retention within the EU. |
| 4.3. | The EESC supports initiatives to improve the circulation of CRM waste within the EU. The simplification and digitalisation of procedures under the Waste Shipment Regulation (WSR), including digital documentation and streamlined administrative processes, are positive steps. The development of a single digital system for waste shipments, with electronic submission and automatic approvals within set deadlines, will help reduce administrative burdens. The Digital Product Passport will further improve traceability and facilitate higher-quality recycling, allowing better monitoring of environmental performance, labour conditions and compliance with due diligence obligations. Regulatory clarity remains critical. Clear and consistent definitions of when a material is considered waste, a product or a substance – particularly at the interface between the WSR and chemicals legislation – are needed to avoid delays in recycling and recovery. |
| 4.4. | Regulatory measures must also be complemented by timely financing and innovation support. The EESC underlines the importance of rapidly deploying funding announced under the RESourceEU Action Plan, including for CRM applications in defence. However, prioritisation decisions require democratic accountability, transparency and clear criteria and must not undermine climate and energy transition needs or public interest. Youth participation should be ensured through advisory roles and structured consultation in CRM governance bodies and programmes. |
5. Facilitating European projects and creating a lasting market
| 5.1. | The EESC supports strengthening the resilience of European CRM value chains through market-based tools, public intervention and strategic coordination. Beyond increasing supply, greater attention should be given to strengthening the quality, predictability and resilience of demand through material efficiency, better product design, higher recycling rates, reducing waste and extending product lifespans while supporting the scaling-up of sustainable European production. |
| 5.2. | Stockpiling can help manage short-term supply shocks but cannot be a substitute for the development of domestic production and processing capacity. Strengthening EU-based projects (3) is of strategic importance to reduce dependencies. Industry concerns regarding ownership models, market distortion and crowding-out effects must be balanced against resilience objectives. |
| 5.3. | Regarding the proposed amendment to the Critical Raw Materials Act (CRMA) on supply diversification, the EESC supports supply-chain risk assessments and greater transparency but stresses that diversification obligations must remain proportionate and feasible. Companies should not be required to diversify where no viable alternative sources exist. Commission intervention should focus primarily on enabling measures, such as support for EU production, before considering mandatory diversification requirements. The EESC also stresses the importance of transparency on material flows data, allocation decisions, stock levels and public financial exposure. A European raw materials transparency dashboard should be established to allow democratic oversight and informed public debate. |
| 5.4. | The EESC emphasises that diversification is not an end in itself. The objective must be to reduce vulnerability and ensure that any increase in extractive activities strictly adheres to and improves sustainability standards while moderating demand. Partnerships should therefore form part of a broader strategy that integrates supply security with environmental integrity and global equity. |
6. Partnering with third countries to diversify
| 6.1. | Trade diversification is a necessity. The EESC welcomes the Commission’s intention to conclude CRM partnerships and integrate the EU’s value chain with strategic partners. Partnerships should support third countries in moving up the value chain and developing their own industrial capacity. |
| 6.2. | At the same time, external partnerships cannot be a substitute for strengthening domestic EU capacities. In several cases, global competitors have moved faster to secure strategic resources before European partnerships can materialise (4), highlighting the importance of developing capacities within the EU. |
| 6.3. | Partnerships must include strong governance safeguards. Agreements should include measurable benchmarks, transparency requirements and suspension clauses for cases such as serious environmental harm, terrorist financing, money laundering, corruption or labour rights violations. Strategic designation must not shield projects from accountability mechanisms and the Memorandums of Understanding and Roadmaps should be public. Attention should be also paid to corruption risks, transparency regarding revenue, fair distribution of benefits, documentation and roadmaps, beneficial ownership reporting and alignment with international initiatives, to prevent resource revenues from fuelling instability or elite capture. The EU’s response to geopolitical competition should not replicate extractive power politics as strategic autonomy must be built on predictable rules and fair partnerships. Therefore, by including the principle of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (ILO 169), partnerships must ensure that affected indigenous peoples, where relevant, have meaningful decision-making power over projects impacting their territories. |
| 6.4. | The right balance must be struck between diversifying supplies abroad and boosting homegrown capabilities when signing FTAs. Preferential tariff treatment for CRMs produced at scale in third countries (particularly zero-tariff access), should be carefully assessed where it risks weakening incentives to invest in EU-based production and recycling capacity. Trade policy should therefore support diversification without exacerbating carbon leakage or further dependence on external suppliers. |
| 6.5. | Finally, partnerships should also reflect partner country priorities and support local economic development through investment, skills transfer and sustainable value creation, while respecting environmental limits, social rights and community consent. They should avoid reproducing extractive dependencies or externalising environmental and social costs. To be credible, partnership agreements and related instruments should include explicit labour rights and enforceable due diligence provisions, with monitoring, transparency and remedies where harm occurs, rather than relying on voluntary provisions. |
Brussels, 17 June 2026.
The President
of the European Economic and Social Committee
Séamus BOLAND
(1) In practice, the cumulative effect of these conditions is that energy-intensive industries already receiving indirect ETS cost compensation are effectively excluded from benefiting from this electricity price relief. The cap on eligible consumption and price, combined with strict investment earmarking and non-cumulation rules, means that companies reaching the maximum allowable indirect cost compensation cannot access additional relief.
(2) Even the EIB (known as Europe’s climate bank) reported in early 2025 that it is only 1 % EU Taxonomy compliant, stressing the overcomplexity and unworkability of the Taxonomy. (Source: Financial Times).
(3) The EESC notes that a single gallium investment project in the EU, when fully realised, could cover up to 100 % of EU demand, significantly strengthening security of supply for key industrial and defence value chains.
(4) In late 2025, the United States secured a major commitment of up to USD 465 million from its Development Finance Corporation to back expansion of a Brazilian rare earth project, moving just days before EU officials were due to engage on the same supply opportunity. (Source: link).
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/C/2026/4655/oj
ISSN 1977-091X (electronic edition)